The Diary of Petr Ginz by Elena LappinMy review
rating: 3 of 5 stars
A rare historical find, the diaries reflect the day to day activities of a Jewish boy in Prague during 1941 - 1942. Unfortunately, the diary as a standalone book is somewhat banal. Many of the entries are simply talk about the weather and what happened in school that day.
Peppered throughout the books are glimpses of the oppression the Jews were facing. You do get to see some of his personality - he has a sense of humor. On the very first entry, he mentions that all of the Jews in town are required to wear a star on their lapel. He calls his classmates sheriffs and designates his street as the Milky Way. He also was a little bit of a prankster and mad scientist of his class. He made little cannons and exploding pencils.
The book became much more interesting to me when I googled the names and dates in the book. I don't understand why the editor claims to have the diaries from 1943 - 1944 up until he was sent to the concentration camp, and the editor even mentions that they were very interesting and full of emotional tension. She even teased us in the introduction with a few excerpts. Why weren't these diaries published?
Another point, while it's completely understandable, some of the more traumatic events in that time period, he skipped writing in the diary. When his best fried was sent to a concentration camp, he doesn't even write an entry for five days. I figured out by looking online and reading the notes in the back of the book that his friend Harry was deported and sent to an extermination camp around the missing days of Petr's diary. I don't blame him for being too upset to write, but when I simply read the diary - it seemed like nothing interesting happened that week. I had no idea that there was a whole story around those missing days.
I think some more clever editing would have helped out a lot. In the back of the book, there are detailed notes explaining the events in history, or some of the cultural references Petr made. I think these should have been printed next to each other. First of all, I didn't know that the notes existed until I finished the diary. By then I was already Googling all of this information on every other page. And I got to the notes, and they didn't make any sense unless I flipped back to the original diary entry. Some clever editing would have made this book so much better.
All in all, I found it an interesting document, but not a compelling read.
View all my reviews.
